Skip to content
Shotline Diving
  • Home Page
    • American Seaway Project
    • Kingston Project
    • Picton Project
    • Verifed by Mark & Roman
      • Listing of Shore Dives
  • Our 3D Models
  • Blog
  • SLD’s Youtube Channel
    • Video Directory
    • Dan Gildea’s Video Archive – SLD US Side
    • Spikes Video Archive – Historical
  • Reference Documentation
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contributor’s Acknowledgment Page
    • Keyword Search Cheat Sheet
    • Shotline Diving’s Glossary Terms.
    • Shotline Diving Knowledge Base Portal

Abandoned

12
  • Alice G C 107169
  • Calumet Island Lifeboat
  • Cambridge US 5399
  • City of St. Joseph (City of Chicago) US 126627
  • False Squaw
  • Grand View
  • Manhattan US 91905
  • Monarch
  • North Colborne Island Barge
  • Northern Lights (1899)
  • Unknown Skiff
  • William P. Rend

Ashore

4
  • Advance US 365
  • Albany (1846)
  • Ariadne (1871)
  • Cambridge US 5399

Burnt at Dock

2
  • Bob Foote
  • Robert K

Collision

15
  • Albany (Orion) US 106306
  • Carlingford US 125024
  • Chester B. Jones US 125159
  • Col. A.B. Williams
  • Comet (Mayflower) (1848)
  • Cora W Post C 83299
  • Dunderburgh US 6151
  • F.T. Barney (1856)
  • Glenorchy C 138213 (A.E. Stewart US 10778)
  • Grace A. Channon US 85309
  • Henry J. Johnson
  • New Orleans
  • Oliver Mowat C 92584
  • Silver Lake US 116263
  • Typo (1873)

Explosion (Boiler, Gas, Dynamite)

1
  • Challenge (1853)

Fire

16
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • Charles A. Street US 126485
  • Eliza H. Strong
  • F.B. Gardner US 9198
  • Goliath (1848)
  • Hinckly (1902)
  • Islander US 75508 (J.H. Kelly, John Thorn)
  • Manhattan US 91905
  • Montana US 90501
  • Niagara (1845)
  • Oscar T. Flint
  • Sea Bird US 22368
  • Strathmore (Gordon Campbell) C 116813
  • Tioga US 24167
  • Traveler (1852)
  • William H. Stevens (1886)

Located but Unidentified

4
  • Crystal Wreck
  • North Colborne Island Barge
  • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)
  • Unidentified Thumb Wreck

Pounded to Pieces

5
  • Annabell Wilson US 106475
  • Ariadne (1871)
  • Charles J. Kershaw (Kershaw)
  • City Of Grand Rapids US/C 125743
  • Montana US 90501

Scuttled

11
  • Bermuda US 2160
  • Como
  • Cornwall C 71609 (Kingston, Bavarian, Algerian)
  • Duncan City US 157096
  • Excelsior (George)
  • Finn McCool
  • Hercules (1917)
  • HMS Princess Charlotte (HMS Burlington)
  • Minnetonka (Hopkins)
  • Transfer (William McGregor) US 80268
  • Unknown Skiff

Storm

15
  • Albion (1848)
  • Alexander B. Moore(Northwest) US 105241
  • Aloha C 134264
  • Annie Falconer C 83285
  • Arabia (1852)
  • Barge No. 1 US 00070
  • Benicia Boy
  • City Of Sheboygan (C 104283, later cited C 137894)(US 125128)
  • Eureka C 46229 (US)
  • Indiana (Stone Wreck)
  • Jane Miller C 78022
  • Miztec (1890)
  • Nelson US 18173
  • Regina
  • Rouse Simmons US 110087

Stranded/Grounded

22
  • American Union US 307
  • C. D. Leuty
  • Colorado US 4267
  • Falcon (Kate Buttironi) US 14393
  • Fedora US 120746
  • Forest City US 9914
  • George M. Cox (Ottawa, Puritan)
  • Grand View
  • Herman H. Hettler (Vail)
  • Hesper
  • James C King US 13871
  • James Pickands (1886)
  • Joesph S. Fay US 75315
  • Keystorm C 129749
  • Kiowa (1920)
  • M.M. Drake US 91485
  • Philo Scoville (Scoville, Philo – Midland Rover) US 19620
  • Racer (1856)
  • Strathmore (Gordon Campbell) C 116813
  • Walrus (Gray’s Reef Wreck)
  • Walter B. Allen US 26561
  • William H. Barnum (1873)

Sunk/Foundered

87
  • Albany (1846)
  • Albion (1848)
  • Alexander B. Moore(Northwest) US 105241
  • Algoma
  • Aloha C 134264
  • Arabia (1852)
  • Ava Bradley US 1910
  • Bermuda US 2160
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • C.B. Benson C 125226
  • Cayuga US 126556
  • City Of Detroit US 4378
  • City Of Sheboygan (C 104283, later cited C 137894)(US 125128)
  • Clifton (Samuel Mather)
  • Colonel Ellsworth US 4354
  • Comet US 5683
  • Crystal Wreck
  • D.M. Wilson US 6772
  • Dean Richmond
  • Defiance (1848)
  • Dolphin
  • E.B. Allen US 7818
  • Emma Nielson (1883)
  • Eureka C 46229 (US)
  • Eureka US 8894
  • Fabiola C 72577 (Royal Oak)
  • False Squaw
  • Fletcher US 120142
  • Genesse Chief (1846)
  • George A Marsh C 133750
  • Harriet B(Shenango No. 2, Pere Marquette 16, Muskegon) US 116695
  • Henry Chisholm US 95610
  • Hetty Taylor US 95356
  • HMS Anson ( L'Iroquosie)
  • Howard S. Gerkin (Rosamond Billett, T. P. Phelan) C 130272, US 140953, US 225429
  • I. A. Johnson US 12090
  • Indiana
  • Indiana (Stone Wreck)
  • Iron Chief
  • Ishpeming US 100039
  • Islander US 75508 (J.H. Kelly, John Thorn)
  • J. H. Jones C 90769
  • Jane Miller C 78022
  • John & Alex (1924)
  • John M. Osborne (1882)
  • Katie Eccles C 75911
  • Keuka (A. Stewart and H.J. McAvoy) US 106644
  • Keystorm C 129749
  • Leviathan
  • Lottie Cooper US 140185
  • M. Stalker US 17211
  • Mary Alice B (Quintus, Bonanka, Lomax)
  • Metropole (Sakie Shephard) US 115935
  • Milwaukee (1852)
  • Nelson US 18173
  • Niagara (1845)
  • Niagara US 18714
  • Nightingale US 18123
  • Northwestern (1847)
  • Old Concord US 18923
  • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
  • Panther C 138004
  • Peter W US 248805
  • Pride US 19681
  • Regina
  • Rouse Simmons US 110087
  • S.C. Baldwin US 23957
  • Sagamore US 57932
  • Sevona (Emily P. Weed)
  • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)
  • Southwest US 22359
  • Sport US 115152
  • St. Albans US 23514
  • Storm Spirit
  • Sweepstakes (1856)
  • Tiller Wreck
  • Trade Wind (1853)
  • Troy (1849)
  • Typo (1873)
  • Unknown (False St. Andrew)
  • Vega US 161706
  • Vernon US 161557
  • Walter B. Allen US 26561
  • Walter L. Frost
  • Wasaga (Wissahickon) US 80598
  • Westmoreland
  • William H. Barnum (1873)

Wreck (Verified)

76
  • Albany (Orion) US 106306
  • Aloha C 134264
  • Ann Long (W.E. Gladstone) C 78026
  • Arabia (1852)
  • Ariadne (1871)
  • Benicia Boy
  • Big Bay Sloop
  • Bob Foote
  • Calumet Island Lifeboat
  • Carlingford US 125024
  • Challenge (1853)
  • Checotah (George D Russell) US 85267
  • City of St. Joseph (City of Chicago) US 126627
  • Col. A.B. Williams
  • Comet (Mayflower) (1848)
  • Crystal Wreck
  • Dean Richmond
  • Duncan City US 157096
  • Dunderburgh US 6151
  • Eber Ward (1888)
  • Excelsior (George)
  • F.B. Gardner US 9198
  • False Squaw
  • Fedora US 120746
  • Finn McCool
  • Forest City US 9914
  • George M. Cox (Ottawa, Puritan)
  • Grand View
  • Hercules (1856)
  • Herman H. Hettler (Vail)
  • HMS Anson ( L'Iroquosie)
  • HMS Princess Charlotte (HMS Burlington)
  • I. A. Johnson US 12090
  • Indiana
  • Indiana (Stone Wreck)
  • Iron Chief
  • James C King US 13871
  • James Pickands (1886)
  • John & Alex (1924)
  • Keuka (A. Stewart and H.J. McAvoy) US 106644
  • Keystorm C 129749
  • Kyle Spangler
  • Lottie Cooper US 140185
  • Mary Alice B (Quintus, Bonanka, Lomax)
  • Milwaukee (1852)
  • Miztec (1890)
  • Nelson US 18173
  • Nightingale US 18123
  • North Colborne Island Barge
  • Northern Lights (1899)
  • Oliver Mowat C 92584
  • Ottawa US 3152 (Boscobel C 116391)
  • Panther C 138004
  • Peter W US 248805
  • Richard Winslow US 110003
  • S.C. Baldwin US 23957
  • Sea Bird US 22368
  • Sevona (Emily P. Weed)
  • Silver Lake US 116263
  • Smith Moore (1880)
  • Sophie's Wreck (Amethyst?)
  • Sport US 115152
  • Storm Spirit
  • Superior (1845)
  • Syracuse (1853)
  • Tiller Wreck
  • Tioga US 24167
  • Traveler (1852)
  • Troy (1849)
  • Unidentified Thumb Wreck
  • Unknown (False St. Andrew)
  • Unknown Skiff
  • Walter B. Allen US 26561
  • Wasaga (Wissahickon) US 80598
  • Westmoreland
  • William H. Stevens (1886)

Wrecked

3
  • C. D. Leuty
  • Colorado US 4267
  • Industry US 202323 (C.H. Conover)
  • Home
  • Docs
  • Regional Events and Conservation Efforts
  • 3D Shipwrecks
  • Stranded/Grounded
  • Forest City US 9914

IDENTIFICATION & SITE INFORMATION

  • Vessel Name: Forest City
  • Year Built: 1870
  • Official Number: 9914
  • Vessel Type: Bulk Freighter
  • Hull Material: Wood
  • Dimensions:
    • Length: 216.7 ft
    • Beam: 32.5 ft
    • Depth: 13.8 ft
  • Tonnage: 743.13 Gross Tons
  • Location: Bear’s Rump Island, near Tobermory, Ontario, Georgian Bay, Lake Huron
  • Coordinates: N45° 58.450′ W081° 45.740′
  • Depth: 60 – 150 feet (20 – 50 meters)

VESSEL TYPE DESCRIPTION

The Forest City was a wooden-hulled bulk freighter with a single Deck and three masts, originally designed to transport bulk goods like iron ore across the Great Lakes. Built by Peck & Masters in Cleveland, Ohio, the vessel measured over 216 feet in length and had a Gross Tonnage of 743 tons, with a cargo capacity of 1,300 tons. The ship was robustly constructed to handle the demanding conditions of the Great Lakes, and it became a significant player in the transportation industry of the time.

Decking of the Forest City
photo submitted by
Chuck Abela

The Forest City was launched in 1870 and initially served as a consort to the bulk freight Steamer R. J. HACKET, pioneering the system of towing consorts on the Great Lakes. Throughout its career, the vessel carried large quantities of iron ore and other bulk materials across the Great Lakes, often facing challenging conditions. Over the years, the Forest City underwent several modifications, including being converted into a screw Steamer in 1872, equipped with a steeple compound engine and firebox boilers.

The vessel experienced numerous incidents during its operational life, including groundings, collisions, and mechanical failures. It was Rebuilt in 1881, which saw the addition of a second Deck and adjustments to its dimensions. Despite these challenges, the Forest City continued to serve as a reliable freighter until its tragic end in 1904.

FINAL DISPOSITION

On June 5, 1904, the Forest City met its demise when it ran into Bear’s Rump Island near Tobermory, Ontario, in dense fog. The vessel struck the rocky island and was severely damaged, ultimately sinking in Georgian Bay. Fortunately, the crew was rescued by the Tug JOE MILTON, but the Forest City was lost to the depths of Lake Huron.

LOCATED BY & DATE

The wreck of the Forest City lies in 60 to 150 feet of water off Bear’s Rump Island in Georgian Bay. It remains a popular site for divers, who are drawn to explore the well-preserved remnants of this historic vessel.

NOTMARs & ADVISORIES

The site is marked as a shipwreck and is considered dangerous to surface navigation. Mariners should exercise caution when navigating in the area to avoid potential hazards.

RESOURCES & LINKS

  • David Swayze Shipwreck File: http://www.baillod.com/shipwreck/swayze/
  • Labbie Collection: https://greatlakeships.org/2907793/data?grd=4085
  • Vlada Dekina Forest City
  • Warren Lo Photography
  • 3D Shipwrecks Forest City

3D Model – Forest City

Forest City by 3DShipwrecks on Sketchfab

CONCLUSION

The Forest City serves as a poignant reminder of the perils faced by mariners on the Great Lakes. Despite its robust construction and modifications, the vessel could not escape the dangers of navigation in dense fog and rocky waters. Today, the wreck lies as a testament to its storied past and the challenges of maritime life.

KEYWORDS

Forest City, Bulk Freighter, Lake Huron, Shipwreck, Great Lakes History, Tobermory, Bear’s Rump Island, Georgian Bay, Peck & Masters, Great Lakes Shipping, Marine Archaeology

Related

© 2025 Shotline Diving • Built with GeneratePress
 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.