Identification & Site Information

• Vessel Name: L.D. Coman (also referred to as L.D. Cowan)

• Year of Build: 1848

• Built by: Carrick & Wilkes, Erie, Pennsylvania

• Vessel Type: Wooden Schooner

• Tonnage: 165 tons

• Original Owner: C.M. Tibbats, Erie, Pennsylvania

Vessel Type Description

The L.D. Coman was a wooden Schooner, a vessel type widely used on the Great Lakes for carrying bulk cargo, owing to its ability to handle rough conditions and large loads. Built in 1848, this Schooner played a vital role in regional commerce, navigating various trade routes within the Great Lakes.

History

The L.D. Coman led an eventful life on the Great Lakes, with several ownership changes and modifications through the years. Originally owned by C.M. Tibbats, the vessel operated under multiple proprietors, undergoing essential repairs and upgrades as it aged. In 1863, it sustained significant damage following a collision in the Detroit River but was repaired and returned to service.

On April 29, 1865, a severe storm off Point aux Barques (near Port Austin) on Lake Huron brought tragedy to the L.D. Coman. Despite valiant rescue attempts involving the Tug W.K. Muir, the vessel’s damage was irreparable. The Schooner ultimately broke apart and was declared lost by May 6, 1865. While records do not specify the type of cargo on board or indicate any fatalities from the wreck, the incident underscores the hazards faced by 19th-century sailors on the Great Lakes.

Final Disposition

The L.D. Coman was completely destroyed during the storm in April 1865 near Point aux Barques, Lake Huron. Efforts to save the ship failed due to the severe damage and challenging conditions, leading to its breakup and Total Loss within a week.

Located By & Date

There are no records indicating that the wreck of the L.D. Coman has been located or surveyed. Its remains, if any, have likely scattered or deteriorated in the waters near Point aux Barques.

Notmar & Advisories

No current navigational hazards or advisories are associated with the L.D. Coman, as it broke up entirely upon its wrecking near Port Austin on Lake Huron.

Resources & Links

For further information on Great Lakes shipwrecks:

• Maritime History of the Great Lakes: Maritime History of the Great Lakes

• Great Lakes Ships Database: Great Lakes Ships Database