Skip to content
Shotline Diving
  • Home Page
    • American Seaway Project
    • Kingston Project
    • Picton Project
    • Verifed by Mark & Roman
      • Listing of Shore Dives
  • Our 3D Models
  • Blog
  • SLD’s Youtube Channel
    • Video Directory
    • Dan Gildea’s Video Archive – SLD US Side
    • Spikes Video Archive – Historical
  • Reference Documentation
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contributor’s Acknowledgment Page
    • Keyword Search Cheat Sheet
    • Shotline Diving’s Glossary Terms.
    • Shotline Diving Knowledge Base Portal

Abandoned

58
  • Adjutant Clitz
  • Angler’s Point Wreck
  • Anna
  • Babineau & Gaudry (1866)
  • Calhoun Family Barges
  • Calumet Island Lifeboat
  • Carl’s Wreck
  • Carnegie Bay Schooner
  • Cornelia US 125865
  • Elk
  • Engine Block
  • False Squaw
  • Fox Island Steam launch
  • Friendly Island Pleasure Boat
  • Frontenac Hotel Dockage
  • General Hancock
  • Goose Bay Cris Craft
  • Grand Island Wreck
  • Grand View
  • Grindstone Island Cars
  • Henderson Harbour Barge
  • HMS Haldimand & Underwater Dock – Carleton Island
  • James W. Follette US 116816
  • Jennie Matthews
  • John Ladue
  • Large Pipe Near Kring Point, St. Lawrence River, New York
  • Life Boat near Oconto
  • Loblaws Wreck
  • Marble Barge
  • Marie Annette (1867)
  • Meatball Rowboat
  • Niagara Shoal Steam Launch
  • Niagara Shoal Wreck
  • North Bay Wreck
  • North Colborne Island Barge
  • Ontario Shores Barge
  • Palisade’s Wreck
  • Picnic Point Barge
  • Pond Marina Barge
  • Riverside (1892)
  • Rose Bay Barges
  • Scow Bay Barges
  • Skylark (1865)
  • Speedy
  • Stoney Island Barge
  • Sylvan Shoal Pleasure Craft
  • Tibbets Point Wreck
  • Uncle Paul (1900)
  • Unidentified Wooden Boat
  • Unknown River Barge
  • Unknown Skiff
  • Vanderbilt Island barge
  • Washington Island Shipyard
  • Waterson Point Barge
  • Welcome Island Sailboat
  • Wellesley Island Barge
  • Whiskey Island Cabin Cruiser
  • Whiskey Shoal Pleasure Craft

Ashore

3
  • Calhoun Family Barges
  • Edith II
  • General Hancock

Buried by Landfill

1
  • Marble Barge

Burnt at Dock

5
  • Akron US 294
  • Arizona US 1768 (City of Marquette)
  • Cresco US 126020
  • Ottawa US 106257 (A.B. Taylor)
  • United Workman (1891)

Collision

3
  • Catherine
  • Maggie L C 96902
  • Rothesay

Destroyed at (Dock, Breakwater, Harbour)

2
  • Highland Beauty
  • National Yacht Club

Dismantled/Dynamited/Scrapped in Place

1
  • Anna

Fire

14
  • Arizona US 1768 (City of Marquette)
  • Avarand (1902)
  • Brownville Rebuilt as Wm. Avery
  • Crossman (pre 1902)
  • Emma Munson C 61169
  • Island Packet (pre 1809)
  • Islander US 75508 (J.H. Kelly, John Thorn)
  • Oatland C 138107 (William J, Averell)
  • Powhattan
  • Raymond
  • Roosevelt US 203203 ( J.C. Ritchie, Bayville)
  • Sir Robert Peel
  • St. Louis (1864)
  • Thousand Islander US 223896

Located but Unidentified

11
  • 1970s Tri-Hull Pleasure Boat
  • Alexandria Bay Sail Boat
  • Angler’s Point Wreck
  • Henderson Harbour Barge
  • Life Boat near Oconto
  • North Colborne Island Barge
  • Ontario Shores Barge
  • Pleasure Boat – Chris Craft
  • Unidentified Wooden Boat
  • Unknown River Barge
  • Welcome Island Sailboat

Lost (Still Missing)

2
  • Pleasure Craft – Missing (Frank Pyke)
  • Swan

Pounded to Pieces

1
  • East US 47123 (Cantin, Kent)

Recovered

2
  • Fleetwood (John Sharpless, Cicoa Glenvegan, Wairton)US 77587
  • Skylark (1865)

Scuttled

23
  • Angler’s Point Wreck
  • Arizona US 1768 (City of Marquette)
  • Avery, Waldo A. (Phenix/Liberty) US 116816
  • Black Snake
  • Carl’s Wreck
  • Carnegie Bay Schooner
  • Grand Island Wreck
  • Grindstone Island Barges
  • HMS Haldimand & Underwater Dock – Carleton Island
  • Lyman Pleasure Boat
  • Marble Barge
  • Oatland C 138107 (William J, Averell)
  • Ontario Shores Barge
  • Pond Marina Barge
  • Rose Bay Barges
  • Sylvan Shoal Pleasure Craft
  • Unknown River Barge
  • Unknown Skiff
  • USS Liberty
  • Waterson Point Barge
  • Welcome Island Sailboat
  • Whiskey Island Cabin Cruiser
  • Whiskey Shoal Pleasure Craft

Storm

2
  • Benicia Boy
  • Gypsy

Stranded/Grounded

3
  • Grand View
  • Keystorm C 129749
  • Oconto (1872)

Sunk/Foundered

36
  • A.E. Vickery US13330 (J.B. Penfield)
  • Alexandria Bay Sail Boat
  • Carl’s Wreck
  • Catherine
  • Chieftain (Chieftain III) C71178
  • Daggerboard Sailboat
  • Eagle (Durham Boat)
  • East US 47123 (Cantin, Kent)
  • Ellsworth Steamer Barge
  • Engine Block
  • False Squaw
  • Farrington US 85554
  • French Creek House Boat
  • Giggle (1929)
  • Grindstone Island Cars
  • HMS Anson ( L'Iroquosie)
  • Islander US 75508 (J.H. Kelly, John Thorn)
  • Keystorm C 129749
  • Kibbets Wreck
  • Meatball Rowboat
  • Niagara Shoal Steam Launch
  • Niagara Shoal Wreck
  • Oconto (1872)
  • Palisade’s Wreck
  • Picton Island Barge
  • Ringleader US 110825
  • Rothesay
  • Roy A Jodrey C 31689
  • Say When
  • Scotland (1863)
  • Stern Wreck
  • Swan
  • Thousand Islander US 223896
  • Uncle Paul (1900)
  • Unidentified Daggerboard Schooner
  • Wellesley Island Pleasure Boat

Wreck (Verified)

73
  • 1927 Cabin Cruiser – Wolfe Island
  • 1970s Tri-Hull Pleasure Boat
  • A.E. Vickery US13330 (J.B. Penfield)
  • Alexandria Bay Sail Boat
  • Angler’s Point Wreck
  • Barcelona
  • Benicia Boy
  • Bigalow H.P. US 96269
  • Calhoun Family Barges
  • Calumet Island Lifeboat
  • Carl’s Wreck
  • Carnegie Bay Schooner
  • Catherine
  • Cresco US 126020
  • Daggerboard Sailboat
  • East US 47123 (Cantin, Kent)
  • Edith II
  • Ellsworth Steamer Barge
  • Engine Block
  • False Squaw
  • Fox Island Steam launch
  • Friendly Island Pleasure Boat
  • Frontenac Hotel Dockage
  • General Hancock
  • Goose Bay Cris Craft
  • Grand Island Wreck
  • Grand View
  • Grindstone Island Barges
  • Gypsy
  • Henderson Harbour Barge
  • HMS Anson ( L'Iroquosie)
  • HMS Haldimand & Underwater Dock – Carleton Island
  • Island Packet (pre 1809)
  • Keystorm C 129749
  • Kring Point Pleasure Craft
  • Life Boat near Oconto
  • Lyman Pleasure Boat
  • Meatball Rowboat
  • National Yacht Club
  • Nekick (Nakick, Flora)
  • Niagara Shoal Steam Launch
  • Niagara Shoal Wreck
  • North Bay Wreck
  • North Colborne Island Barge
  • Oatland C 138107 (William J, Averell)
  • Oconto (1872)
  • Ontario Shores Barge
  • Palisade’s Wreck
  • Picnic Point Barge
  • Picton Island Barge
  • Pleasure Boat – Chris Craft
  • Pond Marina Barge
  • Ringleader US 110825
  • Rose Bay Barges
  • Rothesay
  • Roy A Jodrey C 31689
  • Scow Bay Barges
  • Sir Robert Peel
  • Stern Wreck
  • Stoney Island Barge
  • Sylvan Shoal Pleasure Craft
  • Thousand Islander US 223896
  • Unidentified Daggerboard Schooner
  • Unidentified Wooden Boat
  • Unknown River Barge
  • Unknown Skiff
  • USS Liberty
  • Vanderbilt Island barge
  • Washington Island Shipyard
  • Waterson Point Barge
  • Waterson Point Wreck
  • Welcome Island Sailboat
  • Whiskey Island Cabin Cruiser

Wrecked

2
  • Ellsworth Steamer Barge
  • Nekick (Nakick, Flora)
  • Home
  • Docs
  • St. Lawrence Seaway Dive Sites
  • American Seaway
  • Fire
  • Oatland C 138107 (William J, Averell)

Identification & Site Information

  • Vessel Name: Oatland (formerly known as William J. Averell)
  • Vessel Type: Wooden Package Freighter
  • Location: Button Bay, Wolfe Island, St. Lawrence River
  • Coordinates: Latitude 44°09.0547’N, Longitude 76°20.5399’W
  • Depth: 0.3 meters (1 foot) at its shallowest point, with parts of the wreck visible above the water
  • Length: 75 meters (246 feet)
  • Final Disposition: Scuttled in Button Bay, Wolfe Island near Cape Vincent, New York, in Lake Ontario, 1931

Vessel Type Description

The Oatland, originally built as the William J. Averell, was a wooden package freighter designed to transport goods such as grain, manufactured products, and building materials across the Great Lakes and the St. Lawrence River. Constructed in 1884, the ship featured a fore and aft compound engine and typical late 19th-century freighter designs, including diagonal strapping and two funnels. It was a powerful and efficient cargo carrier for its time.

History

Construction and Launch Launched on March 29, 1884, by Detroit Dry Dock in Wyandotte, Michigan. Built for Ogdensburg Transportation Co., the shipping division of the Ogdensburg & Lake Champlain Railroad, at a cost of $70,000.

Tonnage: Gross Tonnage: 1,603.14 tons Net Tonnage: 1,425.43 tons Cargo Capacity: 43,000 bushels of wheat or 1,450 tons on a 14-foot Draft.

Operational Years

The Oatland primarily transported grain from western regions to Ogdensburg, New York, for rail transport eastward. Additionally, it carried manufactured goods and building stone westward.

Incidents and Modifications

  • 1885: Owners defaulted on payments, leading to winter repairs (1885–1886).
  • 1890: Ran aground on South Manitou Island, Lake Michigan, on June 13.
  • 1894: Received a new propeller.
  • 1899: Ownership transferred to Rutland Transit, following Central Vermont Railroad’s acquisition.
  • 1916: Sold to Great Lakes Transit Co., then transferred to Canadian registry under Lake & River Transportation Co., Montreal. Vessel was lengthened at Cantin’s Dry Dock, Montreal.
  • 1921: Became part of Canada Steamship Lines after Montreal Transportation Co. fleet dissolution.
  • 1927, the ship was retired and laid up in Kingston, Ontario.
  • 1931: Officially declared Abandoned, partially dismantled, and scuttled near Cape Vincent, New York.

Final Disposition

The wreck now lies submerged in Button Bay, Wolfe Island, in the St. Lawrence River. Over time, natural forces have fragmented the vessel. Some Hull portions remain visible above the waterline, posing a hazard to surface navigation.

Current Condition & Accessibility

Condition: The wreck is heavily deteriorated, with parts of the Hull breaking apart due to natural forces.

Accessibility: Shallow water makes the site accessible, though caution is necessary for divers and boaters. Visible Hull fragments above the waterline indicate the wreck’s position clearly.

Resources & Links

  • Great Lakes Maritime Database: Comprehensive data on freighters like the Oatland Great Lakes Maritime Database
  • Maritime History of the Great Lakes: Historical data on shipwrecks and freighter operations. Maritime History of the Great Lakes
  • Wrecksite EU: Global resource for shipwreck data, including Great Lakes wrecks. Wrecksite EU
  • Library and Archives Canada: Registration records and historical documents for Canadian vessels.Library and Archives Canada

Conclusion

The wreck of the Oatland tells the story of a once-prominent package freighter that served both U.S. and Canadian interests. Its transition between ownerships and operational duties reflects the economic shifts of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Today, the remnants of this vessel serve as a historical artifact and a reminder of the maritime legacy of the Great Lakes and the St. Lawrence River.

Keywords

Oatland, William J. Averell, Wooden Freighter, Wolfe Island, Button Bay, Lake Ontario Shipwreck, Great Lakes Maritime History, Scuttled Vessel, Shallow Wreck.

Related

© 2025 Shotline Diving • Built with GeneratePress