Legacy Notes & Full Historical Record

This section preserves the original unedited Shotline content for this wreck so that no historical detail is lost as we transition to the new logbook format.

Identification & Site Information:

• Name: Fayette Brown
• Type: Three-masted wooden schooner
• Builder: Stevens & Presley, Cleveland, Ohio
• Date Built: 1868
• Measurements:
  • Length: 178.5 ft (54.4 m)
  • Beam: 31.3 ft (9.5 m)
  • Depth: 12.8 ft (3.9 m)
  • Gross Tonnage: 553 tons
  • Net Tonnage: 525 tons
• Owner: M. A. Bradley, Cleveland, Ohio
• Master at Time of Sinking: Capt. Halstrum
• Date Lost: June 4, 1891
• Location of Wreck: Near Pelee Passage, Lake Erie, 8 miles below “The Dummy” lighthouse
• Depth of Wreck: Approximately 60 ft (18.3 m)

Vessel Type:

The Fayette Brown was a cargo schooner, built for transporting heavy loads across the Great Lakes. Its three-masted design allowed for efficient sailing and handling of large freight, including its last cargo of brownstone blocks.

Description:

The Fayette Brown was constructed in Cleveland in 1868, designed to meet the growing needs of maritime trade on the Great Lakes. With a robust wooden hull and significant cargo capacity, it transported a variety of goods throughout its operational life.

Notably, the vessel had a history of accidents. In September 1872, it foundered in nearly the same area where it would ultimately meet its end in 1891.

Final Incident and Sinking:

On June 4, 1891, in foggy conditions near Pelee Passage, Lake Erie, the Fayette Brown collided with the steamer Northern Queen. The collision occurred almost stem-on, resulting in rapid flooding and the schooner sinking to the bottom in approximately 60 feet of water.

• Cargo: 176 brownstone blocks.

• Rescue: One crewman leapt aboard the Northern Queen, while others climbed the schooner’s masts. The steamer Robert Millsrescued the remaining crew.

• Fatalities: None reported.

The wreck posed a hazard to navigation and was later removed by the Amherstburg wrecker F. B. Hackett after legal disputes over ownership were resolved.

Historical Legacy:

The Fayette Brown was an integral part of Great Lakes commerce in the late 19th century. The vessel’s loss underscores the dangers of navigating Lake Erie, especially in foggy conditions, where collisions were a common risk.

Located By & Date Found:

The wreck’s exact location near Pelee Passage was known immediately after the sinking. It was removed as a navigational hazard shortly thereafter, leaving minimal physical remains.

Notmars & Advisories:

• Hazards: None currently, as the wreck was removed.

• Historical Context: The location near Pelee Passage and “The Dummy” lighthouse is historically significant due to frequent maritime activity and incidents.

Resources & Links:

• David Swayze Shipwreck File
• Maritime History of the Great Lake
• Great Lakes Ships

Conclusion:

The Fayette Brown was a testament to the challenges of Great Lakes shipping in the late 19th century. Despite its robust construction and storied career, the vessel’s ultimate fate highlights the hazards of foggy conditions and the congested waterways of Lake Erie. While the wreck no longer poses a navigational risk, its story endures as part of the rich maritime history of the region.

The schooner FAYETTE BROWN was a three-masted wooden schooner that was built in 1868 by Stevens & Presley in Cleveland, Ohio. It had a length of 178.5 feet, a beam of 31.3 feet, and a depth of 12.8 feet. The gross tonnage of the vessel was 553 tons, and the net tonnage was 525 tons. fayette-brown-us-9784 1891-06-04 07:48:00