Dredge GORDON

3 min read


Dredge Gordon. by Capt. Tim Caza on Sketchfab	Dredge 100ft 30m length Depths Not Disclosed Lake Ontario, Near Oswego NY GPS not Disclosed

In the dark waters of Lake Ontario, on a treacherous night in November 1879, a small fleet of boats embarked on a journey that would end in disaster. The dredge Gordon and its accompanying vessels, owned by Hickler & Arnold Company, set out from Cape Vincent with hopes of reaching Oswego. Little did they know that this ill-fated voyage would forever be etched in history as a tragic tale of heroism and loss. Join us as we delve into the captivating and heartbreaking events that unfolded on that stormy night.

The fleet was composed of five tugboats, three dredges, and ten scows, all under the command of Captain Fleming of the tug Seymour. The purpose of their voyage was to return from their work on the Lachine Canal system in Montreal. With the Seymour leading the way, the fleet set off, with the intention of seeking shelter in Sacketts Harbor for the night.

However, fate had other plans for the crew of the Gordon. As the fleet approached Tibbets Light, a pivotal decision was made that would alter the course of their journey. Mr. Arnold, a junior partner in the Hickler & Arnold Company, ordered the fleet to change their destination to Oswego. This decision would prove to be fateful, as the storm intensified and the waves grew more violent.

The once calm waters of Lake Ontario transformed into a furious tempest, testing the limits of the tow lines that connected the vessels. As the storm raged on, the line between the Gordon and the rest of the fleet snapped, leaving the dredge vulnerable to the elements. Unaware of the chaos unfolding behind them, the tug Seymour continued its course towards Oswego.

Amidst the chaos and devastation, tales of heroism emerged. Tom Smith, the engineer of the Gordon, became a symbol of courage and resilience. His quick thinking and bravery saved not only his own life but also the lives of two other crew members. Their gripping survival story captivated the public’s imagination and shed light on the immense challenges faced by those on board.

Unfortunately, not all the crew members were as fortunate as Smith and his companions. The sinking of the Gordon resulted in the loss of several lives, including Richard Arnold, Patrick Logan, Billy Logan, George Palmer, and his wife. Their valiant struggle to survive in the frigid waters ended tragically, leaving a void in the hearts of their loved ones.

As news of the disaster spread, investigations were launched to determine the cause of the sinking and the possible negligence that led to such a tragic outcome. Questions were raised about the decisions made by the fleet’s captains and the actions of the tugs that played a role in the chain of events. The legal repercussions and the emotional aftermath would continue to haunt those involved for years to come.