Polly M Rogers US20406

Vessel Type Description #

The Polly M. Rogers was a wooden schooner, a popular vessel type used throughout the 19th century on the Great Lakes. Schooners were known for their cargo-carrying capacity and maneuverability, especially in rough waters. The Polly M. Rogers primarily transported bulk goods like grain, coal, and lumber, essential for the economic growth of the Great Lakes region.

History #

Built in 1870 by George Hardison in Charlotte, New York, the Polly M. Rogers was a well-crafted schooner, regularly transporting goods across the Great Lakes. The ship had a gross tonnage of 346 tons and was robust enough to survive rough lake conditions. After two decades of service, including a grounding incident on Starve Island Reef in 1889, the ship met its end in 1890 during a tow from Fair Haven to Ogdensburg, New York. A storm broke the ship loose from its tow, causing it to crash near Pigeon Island in Lake Ontario.

Final Disposition #

The Polly M. Rogers grounded near Pigeon Island during rough weather in 1890 and was declared a total loss. Valued at $9,300, the vessel and its cargo were unsalvageable. Despite salvage attempts by the Kingston Wrecking Company, the ship’s remains were dismantled after severe damage.

Salvage and Aftermath #

All nine people aboard, including the mate’s wife and child, were rescued in a dramatic operation. Salvage efforts were unsuccessful due to extensive damage, and the ship was left to decay on the shoreline.

Cultural and Historical Significance #

The wreck of the Polly M. Rogers is a reminder of the dangers faced by Great Lakes sailors in the 19th century. Its story, along with its remains near Pigeon Island, stands as a testament to the rich maritime history of Lake Ontario.