There seems to be some confusion and uncertainty regarding the identity of the sunken vessel in the Straits.
According to reports from January 31, 1857, a brig named SANDUSKY, carrying a cargo of wheat, sank with all hands during a gale in the Straits. The incident resulted in the loss of seven lives and property worth $18,000.
However, on September 24, 1856, the schooner L.M. MASON reported passing a different brig sunk in the Straits, with the crew clinging to the rigging. It was believed to be the brig SANDUSKY, which was sailing from Chicago to Buffalo. The weather was stormy at the time, and no assistance could be provided.
Later on, it was reported that there was doubt about the identity of the sunken vessel. Some believed it to be the brig SANDUSKY, while others visiting the spot where the top-masts were visible were confident that it was the ROBERT EMMETT. As of October 4, 1856, there was no news about the fate of the SANDUSKY, and it was uncertain whether it was also lost or not.
