The 19th century was a tumultuous era for maritime trade on the Great Lakes. Vessels of all kinds navigated these inland seas, braving treacherous waters and unpredictable weather. Among these ships was the schooner Commodore Chauncey, a vessel that left its mark on history with a fateful journey in 1858. From its construction to its tragic demise, the Commodore Chauncey’s story sheds light on the challenges faced by sailors and shipbuilders during this era.
Built before 1849, and likely after 1837, the schooner Commodore Chauncey was initially launched in Silver Creek, New York. Constructed by Charles Huntrey or Hemsley, this wooden schooner had two masts and measured 64 feet and 1 inch in length, with a beam of 19 feet and 1 inch. Its distinctive design boasted a depth of 7 feet and 7 inches. Owned by Chauncey Lamphere of Silver Creek, New York, the vessel was poised to become a familiar sight on Lake Erie.
Throughout its early years, the Commodore Chauncey embarked on numerous voyages, carrying cargoes ranging from lumber to staves. In 1854-55, the ship underwent a significant transformation. Charles Stevens Shipyard in Irving, New York, oversaw the rebuilding process, ensuring the vessel’s continued service on the Great Lakes. As it emerged from reconstruction, the Commodore Chauncey continued to sail under the ownership of Captain R.N. Bigelow.
The year 1858 marked a turning point in the Commodore Chauncey’s history. On August 30th, tragedy struck as the schooner found itself caught in a violent storm between Point Abino and Gravelly Bay in Ontario, Canada. Battling the relentless waves and unforgiving winds, the vessel capsized and eventually foundered. Amidst the chaos, initial reports suggested that the entire crew had perished, leaving a somber cloud over the event.
In the face of despair, hope emerged. Later investigations revealed that the crew members had managed to survive the disaster by swimming ashore. This remarkable twist in the tale offered a glimmer of resilience in the face of adversity. The crew’s survival stood as a testament to their courage and determination, showcasing the indomitable spirit of sailors who braved the unpredictable waters of Lake Erie.
The legacy of the schooner Commodore Chauncey lives on through the annals of maritime history. Its tragic loss, while devastating, serves as a reminder of the challenges faced by sailors and the power of the elements. The story of the crew’s survival reminds us of the courage and strength that defined those who sailed these waters. Through its journey, the Commodore Chauncey pays homage to the endurance of the vessels and the people that navigated the Great Lakes during a pivotal era of maritime exploration and trade.
